The thing is though, the 2013 Red Sox were a 'drive up the count' offence and it succeeded quite well, leading the majors in runs scored. If it fails the next year is it because the system no longer works, or just that the hitters collectively stunk?
I do get the argument that this system may not work as well any more, though. I think, in fact, that part of the reason we're seeing run-scoring continue to slide is that pitching and defense have the edge now with technology - computerized analysis of hitter's tendencies dictating pitching patterns, fielding positioning etc.