I was just thinking...
Manny's main goal is to at one point focus completly on hitting and not worry about the rest of his game, right? So he's a natural DH in-the-making and at some point he'll be back in the AL because of it right? He'd probably absolutely love to be a DH anywhere - happy camper, right?
So how shrewd would it be to bring Manny back at say, 20x4 (under the selling point "Power hitters like Manny are hard to come by right now.." and even sell the whole "David/Manny" thing again for half the year) have Manny play left, with Bay in right and Drew in center with Ells and Coco on the bench, then trade Ortiz in a deadline trade that would no doubt bring something of great value even if short term, move Manny into the DH spot, stick Bay back in left then resign him after the season?
Yes, 20/yr for a DH is expensive, but that's what Manny's going to be paid by someone in 2012 when he's finally a DH for the Angels or whoever - so why not the Sox and right now? And do you think Manny of all people would take same money in LA if he had to play defense every night over same money in Boston and just DHing?
Ok guys, rip it up!