Jump to content
Talk Sox
  • Create Account

2017 MLB Trade Deadline Mega Thread (non Red Sox version)


Recommended Posts

Posted

Wow!

 

Quintana was the guy I have wanted for years. He is paid less than Sale and has one more year of team control.

 

This makes the Cubs a very strong team for the next 4 years.

 

I'm not saying we should have offered this, but does this deal outweigh what the Cubs got from the CWS?

 

Devers, Travis, Lakins & Beeks?

 

Devers, Groome & Ockimey?

 

Groome, Travis, Lin & Lakins or Beeks?

 

Or, would it have taken all our big 3?

Posted
Quintana has been a hell of a pitcher for awhile. Pissed we let him go for nothing. He's 28 and from 2014-2016 he averaged nearly 5WAR. Even in a down year, he's on pace for close to 4WAR in the AL and had been trending up. The Cubs were willing to give up two top 100 prospects, one of which is top 5 in all of baseball.
Posted
Quintana has been a hell of a pitcher for awhile. Pissed we let him go for nothing. He's 28 and from 2014-2016 he averaged nearly 5WAR. Even in a down year, he's on pace for close to 4WAR in the AL and had been trending up. The Cubs were willing to give up two top 100 prospects, one of which is top 5 in all of baseball.

 

I've always loved Quintana and his low cost contract. He's got 3.5 years of team control.

Posted
Doolittile and Madson to the Nats for Blake Treinen and two other minor leaguers in A or lower. I get the upside of he 19 yr old who's on the shelf with TJS, but that seems awfully light for two closer level performers
Posted
Doolittile and Madson to the Nats for Blake Treinen and two other minor leaguers in A or lower. I get the upside of he 19 yr old who's on the shelf with TJS, but that seems awfully light for two closer level performers

 

Treinen was better than Madson just last year, and Doolittle gets hurt a lot. The package looks OK.

Posted
I know Martinez might be a rental, but that price doesn't seem steep at all. If I knew that was the price I wish Sox would've jumped on that..
Posted
I know Martinez might be a rental, but that price doesn't seem steep at all. If I knew that was the price I wish Sox would've jumped on that..

 

Yeah, it's light. The headliner was acquired from Toronto for Cliff Pennington two years ago.

Posted
Martinez is great, but I don't know what we would have done with him...much as you might wish Hanley wasn't here, he is, and he's not been nearly bad enough to justify a Pablo-style banishment and writing off of his salary.
Posted

We don't need a LF'er.

 

We don't need a DH.

 

I'd love to add a big bat, but adding one at one of those two positions doesn't make much sense to me.

 

3B, 1B and C are our three weakest offensive positions. I don't see a big bat catcher out there I'm willing to overpay for. I see Devers as our 3Bman of the future, so getting a rental might make sense, but what available, rental 3Bman is a high impact offensive threat?

 

That leaves 1B. JF & DD aren't even willing to move Moreland out of the 4 slot, even though he has slumped for over a month and has been battling a toe injury. I'm not sure they are actively seeking an upgrade at 1B.

 

I just don't see any type of big deal making sense to me. Those wanting a big bat might think trading for Beltre or Alonso is the answer, and while those two make more sense than trading for a LF'er, I think the cost will be too high. We'd need to deal Devers and/or Groome for Beltre, and I doubt we can get Alonso for Chavis, Ockimey, Lakins & Beeks.

 

Posted
Per sources, Yankees have acquired Robertson, Frazier, Kahnle for several minor leaguers - most notably last year's 1st rounder Blake Rutherford.
i am hearing Rutherford and 3 prospects

I

  • 2 weeks later...
Posted

  • Gray to the Yankees is “somewhere between likely to inevitable,” according to Sherman, who reports that the trade could happen Sunday. An executive who has been involved in Gray talks told Sherman that the Yankees are “holding firm” in what they’re willing to offer because they’re not convinced there are any other serious bidders. In case their negotiations with the A’s collapse, the Yankees are discussing starters with other teams as fallback options, per Sherman.

Posted
The Cubs aren't messing around. You're seeing the top teams in an arms race here. The Stros need to make a splash in their rotation and I wouldn't count the Dodgers out from getting some Kershaw insurance. If the prices rise out of control, I'd be fine with NYY staying out of it. Plenty of teams with good farms seem to be making one last effort to stay on top. We can always just flash the cash and get Darvish at the end of the year
Posted
Dodgers To Acquire Yu Darvish

 

By Jeff Todd | July 31, 2017 at 3:14pm CDT

The Dodgers and Rangers have pulled off a last-minute stunner, striking a deal that sends star righty Yu Darvish to Los Angeles, Ken Rosenthal of MLB Network reports.

3:30pm: Three prospects will head to Texas, per ESPN.com’s Buster Olney (via Twitter). Second baseman/outfielder Willie Calhoun looks to be the headliner, per MLB.com’s Jon Morosi (Twitter link). The other two pieces are righty A.J. Alexy and infielder Brendon Davis, Jeff Passan of Yahoo Sports tweets.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
The Talk Sox Caretaker Fund
The Talk Sox Caretaker Fund

You all care about this site. The next step is caring for it. We’re asking you to caretake this site so it can remain the premier Red Sox community on the internet.

×
×
  • Create New...