Early in the off-season, I was in favor of trading Duran. After the Gray and Suarez acquisitions, keeping Duran's offense, even as a DH, seemed like a good idea. I wasn't down on Yoshida, but there was a pretty good chance that Abreu would outplay him, as well as supplying some rotational rest in the OF, and being insurance for an injury.
The plan was good, but didn't anticipate Anthony getting hurt, and neither Yoshida nor Duran hitting anything.