1. Trading Yoshida is a lesser evil than trading Duran or Abreu to create a path for Yoshida.
2. Yoshida is a lefty, Eaton is a righty has speed/utility off the bench, defensively versatile. Eaton is probably a better bench player but can be sent down, and Im okay with sending him down initially while we continue to assess (roster battles continue into the season)
3. I think it is a bad idea to trade Yoshida on 3/6/2026, especially before we ask if he is okay with a minor league assignment. I doubt he'd say yes. This right here, makes it hard for me, a very pro platoon guy, to warrant keeping him on the 26 man in lieu of someone who can hit lefties - but Im willing to start the year with the better bench players in AAA because Yoshida prob wont agree to be sent down.
I think most likely is that we'll send everyone down who we can. SO maybe Eaton makes more sense as a bench role, but sorry bro - you have options - down to AAA. Ditto Ward. Maybe ditto Monasterio too.
Im willing to try somethign outside the box like, oh I dont know, 5 bench players and one less pen arm in April when there are a ton of days off in the first few weeks. Not sure why 5 bench players went extinct, it use to be a real thing.
Im willing to start the year sending everyone down who we can to postpone having to make a decision at that point. Buy ourselves time to continue to assess. Im willing to open Masa on the 26 man. But eventually, someone may force a decision (maybe not, maybe there will always be a revolving door of 2 guys hurt). One key date may be Romys return. For no other reason than - gotta cut someone from teh 26 to make room for Romy and it may force a decision (again, maybe not if someone else is hurt).
Im open to someone pushing Masa off the 26 man eventually. Maybe thats KC, Monasterio, Ward, Eaton...Personally, its not Casas for me. I take Yoshi > Casas all f'ing day. Even if Casas is healthy, hes prob not the same person he was in 2023 , in fact hes prob less athletic/durable today then he was then. He might even be fatter. His bat speed may have slowed down. He might need another full year to get back to where he was in 2023 which wasnt a wartless player. He prob still has holes in his swing/approach like always and slow start like always. This isnt to say that I hate Casas or think we should DFA him today or trade him today (common theme: hoard as many options as you can). But I do have Masa > Casas on my depth chart. And yes, thats even if Contreras gets hurt. Yoshi should learn first base , ive been saying it for a year.