Hugh2

Come on man. 1. it’s a mock draft, not the Sox board. 2. By the time this guy reaches the majors the team needs could be completely different. You have no idea what the roster could look like in 4 years. 3. Said player could be traded. Just like Montgomery was traded for Crochet. It’s why you go BPA.

On People stating that others don’t know the nature of things. I learned a long time ago that no one goes online and argues with the “I used to do this I know what I’m doing you’ve obviously not” it makes someone, anyone who would hypothetically do this sound arrogant, and it comes off as being very condescending. And to say such things that go against the fabric of what we hear from everyone else on planet earth who has played at the top level is just hysterically ironic. I think anyone who makes a habit of insulting everyone who disagrees with their minority opinion as never achieving anything in a condescending way is teetering on the edge of being a troll. those are the facts….and the facts are indisputable

No team on earth has great back ups. Back ups are back ups for a reason. Every team in the universe has an AAA roster that either has a top prospect OR a guy who isn’t good enough to be an MLB starter. Toro/Sogard isn’t bad roster construction. And nobody would be talking about that if Story, Cambell, or Rafaela were hitting.

lol, not really. Bregman WAS looking like an MVP candidate and Mayer/Campbell were waiting in the waiting in the wings. i would challenge people to say how they’d have better constructed the roster. now if you’d be willing to critique your stance to “bad roster management” I’d be inclined to agree.

Our infield is literally. AAAA guy, a guy who has fallen off a cliff, AAA guy and an AAAA guy. Devers at 1B and calling up Mayer would solve a whole lot.

When you go to woo tell us what you see.

Back in April I put the over/under on an Anthony promotion at may 28th....I think. Anthony strikes me as the type of guy who is going to catch on quick.

At this time of year no one is selling yet, he had one and he went down for injury. Most G.M.s in this position would ask their Raffy Devers equivalent to move. As I said earlier I'm not going to berate him, people are who they are and he certainly makes up with it with the bat. Buts' it's disappointing, I think If Devers truly understood the nature of things and wanted him and his team mates to win he'd give 1B a shot. But I just don't think Devers is very interested, he's kind of just a let me get up go to work and I'll do my job leave me alone kind of guy.

Does Cora really not want Raffy at 1B? If Devers was open and willing to move to 1B would Alex Cora be against that? I don't think he would have a problem with it. Also the whole "brez do his job" well he did his job, Sox had a young player regarded with a lot of potential in Casas but he got hurt. Most teams in Brez's position would either call next man up (Toro), trade for a guy, or move someone on the roster to 1B. Can he really trade for a guy? we seem to go through this EVERY YEAR, not me and you just the fanbase in general, but we always want trades to happen in May and they just almost never do. Most teams are still trying to figure out if they're buyers or sellers and will likely wait until July to do so. I'm not really sure what more Brez could do other than grossly overpay for someone, and even then who knows what is out there.

No he's not, I'm sure if the Sox could predict the future they would have traded him and moved Devers to 1B. He might of put up the same stink but I think he'd do it and make the adjustment and settle in like he did at DH.

Yeah but that's just the thing, they have him under control until his age 30 season, or thru his age 29. As good as he is, is he going to age into his 30's? I just don't see any real value in extending, the Sox already have him for another 4.5 years. Sometimes I think you just take the team control. I'd rather roll the dice on guys like Campbell.

Well Casas is (or at least was) their long term plan at 1B. He went down this year. No MLB team has a good player in AAA ready to take over, unless that guy is a prospect working his way up. THey have Toros' like us. Usually teams have a guy veteran who is willing to slide into 1B.

No, that would be fine, but why would Wilyer ever sign that when guys next to him like Rafaela and Campbell are getting much more?

I'm not sold on an Abreu extension. Abreu is hitting .227 with a .664 OPS vs. lefties this year. 0 HR and 2 RBI's and his career line is even worse than that. To be fair the Sox give him very little exposure to lefties, only 103 career at bats. I like Wilyer, I'm happy with him as a player and wouldn't even hate if they gave him a chance to hit lefties (although I do have my doubts if he ever will). But there's no need to extend him. He will be 30 years old when he plays his first season out of team control. The Sox control Abreu throughout his 20's. Also a lot of his value comes in his defense, which is great, but that's not rewarded the same way that home runs and SLG % and he will probably always live in that 450-500 at bat range max the way they use him. That's not a guy who is going to kill you in arbitration. Again I like Wilyer, and just because I don't think he should be extended doesn't mean I don't see him on this team. I just don't think there's a real big risk in not having him in Boston 2030 and beyond.

I’d wish this upon no one, not even Manny Machado.

Story isn’t good on D at all this year. He does not look as good at SS as he has in the past.

I disagree, I think Raffy could make an excellent 1b if he wanted to. I’m not going to castrate him for not wanting to move like others but I’d be lying if I said I wasn’t disappointed. The team would be better with Toro and/or Romney out and Anthony in. And the path of least resistance could have been Raffy to 1B where most thought he would end up before last year.

Anthony is the #1 prospect in all of baseball with well over 250 at bats in AAA. people in his stratosphere are typically never on the “when he’s a good option” plan but rather break their way into the majors one way or another. I get that it’s probably going to be a few more weeks at the very least to see what shakes up, and the MLB roster may open up a spot for Mayer first but there’s zero reason to keep Anthony down. He has very little to learn at that level and should be in the bigs

I don’t know what they’re going to do. It would be easier if Raffy would move to 1B, but if history is any precedent Anthony has to come up soon. if you look at the history of top ranked prospects (1-5) performing in AAA Anthony is already approaching the top half of the list of guys who have been held in AAA the longest.

I was looking at this earlier and was going to save it for later. 1/4 of all of Mayers errors were literally his first handful of games as an 18 year old in the FCL. I feel disgusting even talking about fielding percentage. also comparing him to the best prospect in all of baseball is completely unfair. Not sure what Anthony having higher offensive potential means about Mayers defense and the prospect of moving to 1B. I have to give credit for the unique takes we see here.

I wonder though, is Campbell at 1b because he is going to move there? or is he going to be able to back up there? I still don't believe Campbell is their plan A right now. Mayer, with a good stat line, is in the midst of his first funk but he did draw 3 walks last night. Mayer may or may not be ready, but he's very close. Anthony looks ready, and Mayer is literally just a half a step behind. It may be a little bittersweet because Campbell is going through a funk so perhaps some aren't as excited about more Rookies on the cusp of beginning their big league Journey but this is a pretty cool time. I think it would be pretty awesome if those three just feeded off each others energy. Get them on the same roster!!!!

Story's defense has taken a big step backwards this year. The only thing he does positive is run the bases well. Mayer should be at SS sooner or later and I suspect the Sox will do just that.

Time to sweep the Orioles, get a few games above .500 and help turn Baltimore into sellers

The Boston Red Sox will never permanently move Mayer to 1B. The odds of them doing it for this year is .05% the odds of them making him the long term fixture there is 0%

You're the only person on earth saying Mayer can't be a SS and maybe should move to 1B. kids, because thats what he was, he was drafted as a teenager need to develop on both sides of the ball. Here's what the Pro's say about Mayers defense. Soxprospects.com Instinctual defender with fluid actions. Looks like he is gliding on the field. Soft hands and solid footwork. Moves well and has plenty of range for shortstop. Confident defender; will take a flashy infield. Some long-term concerns about his ability to stick at shortstop as he matures. Organization appeared poised to get him some reps at third base midway through 2024, but injuries, including the one that eventually ended his season after July 30, effectively scuttled those plans. Potential above-average defender at short for the foreseeable future Pipeline (8th overall) The Red Sox landed the fourth overall pick in 2021, their earliest since 1967, and MLB Pipeline's top-rated Draft prospect in Mayer, a California prep shortstop whom some scouts considered the best hitter and defender that year. He has mostly lived up to expectations Bigger than most shortstops, Mayer has below-average speed but his quick first step and instincts help him compensate. he plays a solid shortstop with plus arm strength. Some evaluators like him better at third base, where they believe he could be a plus defender with profile power. Baseball America (8th overall)- Mayer has excellent hands, a strong, accurate arm with the ability to vary his throwing angle, and the anticipation and well-calibrated clock of an above-average to plus shortstop. Some evaluators still wonder if he'll outgrow the position as he adds strength into his 20s, but such a move is unlikely to be considered as he moves through the minors. Though Mayer has below-average speed, his instincts allow him to play faster than his foot speed. What is it you know that they don't that has you saying he should move to 1B?