The Analytical Folks pour through tons and tons of data. But the players/coaches/managers have lived through it all, which should be more valuable.
When asked what the most useless stat was, Torii Hunter once said “whatever one tells you Derek Jeter is a bad defender.”
Needless to say, not all players are on board with analytics.
But then, some of their beliefs are also pretty out there. Wade Boggs thought eating chicken before every game made him a better hitter. Justin Moreau believed to be at his best, he had to leave his car at exactly 13 minutes after the hour. Nuke LaLoosh thought wearing women’s underwear made him a better pitcher.
So yes, I can see why some players’ wisdom might not be so sagely. And in the end, in a game dominated by math, I find myself trusting the math.
Except when it comes to Pat Tabler. That dude was a Clutch Freak Show…