moonslav59

The Sox farm went 4-1, tonight, including a completion game. Woo won 7-1 as Wong homered. Drohan finally got touched up, a bit, but got the win. I Campbell with the save. The offense got 7 hits and 9 BBs! Sogard 2-3 w 2BBs. POR won 5-3 in 10. Mullins K'd 10 in 5.2, but he walked 4 and let up 3 hits (1ER). Anderson got the win going 3.1 while allowing 1 run. Romero 2-4, Jh Garcia 1-4 w BB and Rosario 2-5. GRE lost the completion game but won the full game 5-3. Valera went 4.1, 5H, 2ER, 1BB, 4K. McShane continued to shine by going 2.2 of scoreless pitching. Y Rod 2-3 w HR and BB. Lugo also homered, and Taylor went 3-3 w BB. Salem won 5-4, but allowed 4 in the 9th. Aita looked great. He allowed just 1 hit and no BBs. (7 Ks) Anderson homered and went 2-4 w BB. Cespedes went 3-5.

This routine is getting tiresome. I'm glad Houck looked improved, but now it's two wasted decent starts.

I didn't say you said injuries didn't matter. My point is about how firmly you seem to think just the last 80 games is who a player is, "until he proves otherwise." What is that based on, and why is that number so much more telling than others?

Players go up and down all the time- hardly any stay even all the time. Explain why you think how someone has done in the just the last 81 games is more important or telling than any other time frame or combination of time frames. For example, if a player is hitting .800 over the last 4o games and 16o games, but .600 over the last 80 games, why should we see him as a .600 guy, until he proves otherwise? Plus, when a player's numbers are affected by an injury, shouldn't that temper your judgment,, some?

I like Devers up 4th. The 3 slot has dropped out of favor, so Bregman at 3rd might be wasteful. Campbell 2nd and Bregman 3rd would mess up the lefty-righty thing, but I still like the idea of Campbell 2nd. Maybe Devers 3rd vs LHPs?

Good stuff. I always appreciate your opinions on our farm players. I'm more pumped up on Jh Garcia, and I started out pretty high on him. Is the sample size too small to start second-guessing on Valera? SP was very high on Drohan, before- up to 6th mid '23, and I wonder if maybe they weren't really too high on him. He looks for real, so far.

Time to cut ties with Blaze. Cespedes may come around. Bleis need to get something prolonged going, or he will drop quickly in the rankings. Who knows, sp's keeps Castro up way too high.

He's the hardest player to project. .598 first 24 PAs .997 middle 69 PAs .217 OPS last 38 PAs The two bad stretches are almost the same amount of PAs as the nice stretch.

Broken record. Even 2-3 monts is not who someone is and will forever be. Do you actually believe that? BTW, Casas hit .800 in 2024, including over 1.000 in his last 50 PAs and .778 over his last 175 PAs. Both Devers and Casas were dealing with injury. You cut no slack.

BA is not everything, and again, what someone has done in one month is not who they are.

Yes, he should not be put out there in a game, until he's had plenty of practice and he looks okay and feels okay. That practice should start soon, if the option is to be there. The thing is, Casas ha set the bar so low, on defense, that I find it hard to think Devers can't get to equal in a pretty short time.

Some Farm OPS: Woo .987 Rosier .963 Anthony .909 Toro .845 Eaton .844 Mayer .837 Grissom (.879 Grandal is small sample size) POR .930 Jh Garcia .925 Romero .897 Liendo .869 T Miller GRE .860 Alcantara .830 Bleis .807 A Lugo .800 Ehrhard .777 Taylor, .762 Y Rod SAL .927 A Anderson .804 Arias (in GRE, no) .781 Encarnacion, .776 Asencio OPS Against w 13+ IP .234 Clarke A-/A+ .439 Burdi AAA .445 McShane A- .463 Early AA .481 Mills AAA .489 Drohan AAA & BRooks A- .499 Cohen A- .526 Mullins A+ .550 Stock AAA .583 Sansone A- .636 Uberstine AA .640 Van Belle AAA .645 Ingrassia A+ .662 Carlson A+ .673 Aita A- .703 Sandlin AA

Considering how Devers seemed to be saying he disliked not being out of the field, I would think he'd be agreeable to playing 1B over DH. He must realize he's not playing 3B, anymore for the Sox, even if Bregman bolts after 2025. Mayer is ML ready. Devers knows this. I don't want to presume I know what a plyer feels or wants: I often criticize other posters for doing that, but I think he would likely say yes to 1B, just maybe not now or mid season 2025. Maybe, Sox brass does not want to "stir the beast" after what happened, this past winter, but I'd think it has to be something they have thought of. To me, Casas still has a lot of slack on his "leash," so there is no big hurry, but if one option would be to have Devers play or share time at 1B, once the leash is as tight as it gets, then he needs to start practicing at 1B, pronto. We could end up with some sort of DH/1B share, where Devers and Casas share 1B and DH about 50-50, at least until we find out if Devers is better on D or not, or give Yoshida his shot at DH (maybe Refsnyder v LHPs) and go with Devers at 1B, near FT. DH: Yoshida v R/ Refsnyder v L 1B: Devers LF: Anthony CF: Duran (Rafaela as late inning D w Duran moving to LF) RF: Abreu v R/ Rafaela v L

My guess is, we will wait until winter to make a deal to clear things up, some. We could do something at the deadline, but I seriously doubt we trade a big name like Anthony, Mayer or even Story. Perhaps we deal Rafaela or Abreu, or some minor deal like Refsnyder, Grissom, DHam or lesser names and prospects. We aren't getting any prize trading Refsnyder and Grissom or DHam. Over the winter, I was often told I expected too much in return for Abreu, but I'm not sure that is true, now. I doubt Rafaela brings back a significant return, unless we include a good second tier prospect or a decent pitcher. The likely big trade, IMO, would involve us biting the bullet and choosing to trade Story (with cash) or Mayer and just praying for health. We'd be relying on Rafaela as SS depth until Romero/Arias are ML ready (1.5 to 2 years?) I'm not "for trading" Mayer. I'd rather make a trade like Story, cash and Mullins for Sean Murphy, but I'm not sure how realistic that is. I'm a big Areu fan, but I'm not sure he can ever move beyond being a really good platoon batter with GG defense in a tough RF. That does have great value, and I'd be fine using Rafaela as his platoon partner, once Refsnyder retires and going with Duran in CF and Anthony as the FT LF'er. I'd also be fine with moving Campbell to CF with Duran in LF and Anthony in RF. The RF d would be worse, as would CF D, but we'd have Rafaela as the 4th OF'er and would have something nice to show for the traded Abreu. A slot would be opened up for Mayer, so maybe we'd be a much better team... maybe.

LOL. Your point was "Right now," [He can't hit.} Okay, his 3 game recent sample size supports your claim. My 6 gamer doesn't. I was poking fun at the small and selected sample size positions many of us often use.

I'm not sure Campbell can even play 1B. Can you answer my Q about the downside(s) of Campbell at 3B? I honestly do not know. (Arm?)

They did leave 1B depth pretty barren, but I do think picking up a decent journeyman 1B in May or June might be the easiest position to fill. I think they expected Casas to be ready by May or June, but he got hurt. All-in-all the pre-season plan was not god-awful: they were just slow to react, once they knew Casas was a no go. We all knew Dalbec was a question mark, and his super high K rate is almost always a sign of trouble ahead. That being said, they did have some reason to be optimistic that 1B would not be a major problem. Over Bobby Dee's first 156 gamea (545 PAs,) he hit .243 33 94 with 29 DBL+TRPL. The .308 OBP was not good, but later one, we'd have been thrilled with just that. His .511 OPS looked very promising for a young players first 545 PAs. His OPS was .819 (114 OPS+)

That does look nice. I'm liking someone almost every night, except no game Mondays. AAA has Dobbins, Drohan and Criswell (Stock, Wink and maybe Fitts, at some point.) AA: Early, Monegro, Mullins & Sandlin (Bolden, Wehunt, Uberstine) A+: Clarke, Valera, Tolle, Dean & Rogers (Rivera) A-: Aita, Ehrlicher, Hansen (Sprague) FCL: Cason, Reyes, Fajardo

Thanks for doing this.

What would be the main issue with Campbell at 3B. other than Bregman plays there? 1B: Bregma 2B: Story SS: Mayer 3B: Campbell We should have traded Casas for Castillo & Cash or Woo.

You mean demote the guy with a 1.069 OPS over the last six games? (See: I can use tny sample size, too.)

A pouting Story would be too funny to contemplate.

If Anthony is also called up, it makes Campbell in CF less of an option, and now "rotating" Mayer around the infield is very problematic. Someone would have to go (via trade or IL) to make room for both top prospects, and that's not even bringing up Yoshida. 13 Everyday players C: Narvaez/Wong 1B: Casas (Romy) 2B: Campbell, Mayer (DHam) SS: Story, Mayer 3B: Bregman, Mayer LF: Anthony, Duran CF: Duran, Rafaela, RF: Abreu, Refsnyder, Anthony DH: Devers Without Romy and DHam, there is room for 13, but how do the top 3 prospects play 75-80% or more of the time, and if so, at whose expense? The obvious players losing playing time would be Rafaela & Refsnyder (UGH!) but what infielder? None of these guys can play 1B, except Casas.

This totally blows up a few posters' narratives.

I have, before. When it's late in a season and we are down 1-2 games in the WC race, I think of the many winnable games we let slip away, and sometime a single game or two stick out.