On paper (only) the two players that are on the 26 man roster who could possible help the offense by playing more than Marwin & Dalbec are Arroyo (.273/.702) and Plawecki (.260/.695). Santana has a decent OPS (.791) but low BA (.174).
Imagine, if at the start of the season, I told you I'd bearguing batting Plawecki and Arroyo might be the best solution to boosting a slumping offense! Even these two have OPS around .700, but they beat Marwin's sub ..560 mark and Dalbec's recent numbers.
Arroyo is easy: just play him at 2B and sit marwin, assuming Arroyo is healthy enough to play everyday.
Playing Plawecki means DH'ing Vaz or benching him. Vaz is not even close to our weakest batter, and if you DH Vaz, JD has to play OF, and for who? (Kike to 2B means Arroyo doesn't play.)
Folks, there's not many options for Cora.
If you put our best hitters up 1-5, which I assume means Renfroe batting 5th, or third, if you follow the analytics, our 6-9 hitters will be worse than they are now.
I'm not a fan of Kike up first. If you look at just 2021's OBP (not my way of choosing), Arroyo's .325 OPS wins the prize, and while .325 certainly beats Kike's .291 OBP, we're talking one more time on base 23 more times over 650 PAs- or about one more time a week.
It's worth a try, but don't expect miracles.
Is this worth a try?
1. Verdugo LF
2. Arroyo 2B
3. JD DH
4. Bogey SS
5. Devers 3B
6. Renfroe RF
7. Santana 1B
8. Vaz/Plawecki C
9. Kike CF
(or flip Arroyo and Verdugo)