If Porcello could give us 220 IP at 5.50, would it be worth it?
I'm thinking, in a year with low expectations, maybe getting better than 5.50 from a mix of starters might not only help us in 2021 but also help us get a better read on guys like Pivetta, Houck, Whitlock, Seabold, Mata and maybe even someone else.
That being said, if Porcello could give us 200 IP at 4.50, the whole equation changes.
Somewhere in between is likely to occur, but he may still have a much better season in him. He's not really all that old. He's only 32 and 2 years removed from going 17-7 4.28.
He had a nice FIP,last year (3.33) but a horrific WHIP of over 1.5- worst of his career.
Yes, he's durable, but with all those innings on his arm, maybe he's burnt out. (He has just under 2,100 IP in 12 MLB seasons.)
If he'll take a one year deal- no harm, but I'd rather see what our young starters have.