As the old cliché goes, this is a good problem to have. Yankee fans are talking about heads needing to roll and pissed about things like us getting Whitlock. We're talking about whether to promote a guy who looks like a possible star.
I heartily disagree that there's nothing to lose. What if he stinks for 5 games and we lose 3 or 4 of them? And then what do you do with him?
The leash would be short. We're in a pennant race and every game matters.
Arroyo is on the IL right now, otherwise he would be at 2B.
If Arroyo is 100% healthy, there's no full-time spot for Duran.
If Arroyo is not healthy, boom, there's your opening for Duran (as Kike would play mostly 2B).
Right. It's just not the time.
If they call up Duran right now and he gets off to a rough start, it would not be good for the team or for him. In no time you'd have the stories "Did the Red Sox make a big mistake...?"