I've been a Sox fan since the late Sixties myself.
They also have more titles than any other team this century, but it hasn't knocked any of the Doubting Thomas out of you.
Since it's all opinions, there aren't really any lies. You just tend toward really negative opinions.
You predict losses when the team gets behind 1 or 2 runs early. You predicted we'd go 2-7 in the stretch against division leaders. It's just what you do.
I agree you can't have everybody on the field at once, but guys get beat up and injured, too, and a little insurance is not a horrible thing, especially after a trade deadline...
The onus is always on the reader/viewer/listener to be discerning and skeptical, or to simply tune out altogether. The best policy is to find sources you can actually trust.
He only played 69 total games in 2023 and 2024 combined so your numbers have very little context.
Right now he's playing like the guy they thought they were getting and the shortstop we need. I'm happy about that. But to each their own.
As far as trading Duran or Abreu is concerned, I get why some thinking it was a good idea. But they're both contributing wins to the 2025 team. If you traded one of them at the deadline and the one you kept gets hurt or slumps while the one you traded plays great, then Breslow looks stupid and Talksox is calling for his head.
The thing is, Breslow and his team have vastly more knowledge of all these players than any of us.
Rosenthal claims that the Red Sox have some sort of "efficiency models" that they rely heavily on. From his perspective that's a problem because they're not aggressive enough.
I'm just happy the team is playing as well as it is right now. They're worth watching again. Anthony alone is worth tuning in for.
In the Devers trade the Sox shed approx. 235 in payroll when you factor in Hicks's contract.
In the Mookie trade the Sox shed approx. 72 million-27 Mookie and 45 Price.
I was very disappointed about the deadline moves too, but I think I understand what happened. Breslow didn't want to trade anyone from the current team. I can't fault him for that. And I suspect he was also very reluctant to trade pitching prospects. So that left him with a pool of position prospects that maybe wasn't as strong as Sox fans might think.
If Bailey's lab magic works on May, that could really make things look better. And then you also have the great performance from Criswell last night.