@ southpaw777 (copied from Benintendi thread)
Farrell needs to realize that some guys can actually hit the same side pitcher. Benni has looked good vs LHP. Overall better than JBJ I think..the smart move would have been to PH Young for JBJ vs Layne making Girardi swith pitchers one batter earlier. lets face it, Aaron f***ing Hill strikes fear in exactly zero pitchers, LH or RH, which is why bLayne was left in to face Hill. Young would have forced Girardi to switch. then Benni is up so he would have to go to a lesser LHP since they already used their main LH guy Layne...I just dont understand why Farrell doesnt see this. Girardi schooled his ass last night...Farrell got lucky Young was barely HBP and Betences was off his game because those first two PH moves by Farrell were absolutely ass backwards! the guy is clueless how to manage a game.
Well, it's possible that Farrell expected Girardi to leave Layne in to face Hill and that's what he wanted. Plus Young has been hitting very well against RHP for a while now.
I see your points but there are some counterpoints too. The bottom line was he sent up 2 PHers and 1 of them reached base.