Closers are a volatile commodity - see Brad Lidge, Brian Fuentes, etc. Paps' year so far is pretty poor for him, and the numbers are troubling, but I'd think that he's worth paying the money for at least another year. The Toronto outing was a little unlucky for him - two first pitch swings (which might be the Jays' MO, idk, but it's still very unusual). I wouldn't mind shelling out the money for Putz, Soriano, or Balfour, don't really trust Wheeler, Francisco, or Gregg, and don't really know the rest - except Downs, who I wouldn't imagine is worth the first rounder.