Bennett is fine, but I don't think he needs to be up in MLB this year. Sox need to see if they can get Bello rolling since they signed him to a horrible extension.
As I've heard my son sing in the shower many times when he was in middle school "hope lies in the smoldering rubble of empires." Larry Lucchino knew this. Unfortunately, the empire came home and now NESN is "the numb black screen that be feelin' like home."
It's still important as not all pitches are sent to ABS. You still play a factor throughout the game with passed balls, controlling the running game, etc. Until Fangraphs revises their positional adjustments, CF/2B/3B are staying in third place.
And I also have an overarching problem with how defense is calculated into bWAR vs fWAR. I don't think there's a perfect solution for grading a player's worth. Was Ceddanne really the 14th best OFer last season? His wRC+ was 42 out of 48 qualified hitters.
If he was a projected GG SS, they would have kept him there as it's a much more important position. CF is about as important as 2B and 3B. SS and C are the two most important defensive positions on the field.
He did not have a GG at SS in MiLB. I don't know where you got that from. He had an "average" glove. When he moved to the OF, his defense popped. It was nothing special in the IF.
GM's would trade MORE for Ceddanne if there was no contract attached to him. I can guarantee that his BTV went down after signing his extension. It most likely does for every guy! Therefore, it reduces his trade value!
Even if he "earns the contract" it doesn't really matter. He's not a guy that is breaking the bank. He's not a guy that you need to lock up post arbitration 6 years in advance. His FA years aren't going to be that expensive. Better business practices would be to go year to year with him IMO. There's no real cost savings with what they did with him.
There's no reason to be stuck with guy for 8 years just because they were highly ranked at one point. Once you sign those extensions, they are also harder to trade because other teams don't want to be necessarily be locked into those extensions either.
For Roman? Yes. For Ceddanne? No! Not enough upside as you've said. Sox have enough $$ that worrying about retaining him after his arb years shouldn't be a concern.
Which corner? All four spots are limited in scope and have their own problems connecting with the base of RSN. The problem with TS is that we are way too hyper focused on the Sox day to day. Majority of fans are much more casual. I'd say a lot of Sox fans wouldn't know who Andruw Monasterio is.
Rafaela's OPS was below 650 two weeks ago. We'll see if he can keep up is current pace.
I'm not "bending over backwards" I'm just making an argument. Same thing everyone else on here does every single day. 🫠
The only sham is all these people calling for boycotts and saying they aren't going to watch anymore or that they don't care, but they keep showing up everyday and posting about the team.
SHAM!
Why would you extend someone at FA money? That doesn't make sense. You extend someone with cost savings. If you are extending someone with FA dollars you are a dope.
If you extend Bello for low end money and all you get is a low end starter that you are stuck with, it's a loss! You're better off not being locked in with that guy!