My only real question is that Hamilton was a 2.6 bWAR guy this year. For someone that was seen as the last guy on the 40 man roster, that's really amazing production and quite the breakout performance. I don't think I could give him anything less than a B or B-. I know his defense is subpar, but I think if he was left as a backup 2B/roleplayer, his warts would be diminished. Devers only produced 3.7 bWAR and you gave him an A-.