In my opinion, it does. We can agree to disagree. The fact that the Yankees basically controlled 1/4 of the American League and that it coincided with their dynastic run in the 50's and then their subsequent collapse when Finley bought the team and their talent pool dried up is more than a coincidence. To me, collusion is much worse than money.
Explain to me why Holliday wants to play for the Yankees first, and then the Mets. The Yankees, yes, you can cite money. The Mets? Why come to a team that is terrible? Mismanaged. Maybe...just maybe, he wants to play in NEW YORK. How come he didn't list Boston, or Philly, or LA?
If anything, this is not all that bad for Boston. This all but assures Bay coming back to Boston, and the loss of Matsui/Damon.
Matsui will be lucky to break 8 million, and Damon will be hard pressed to break 10. Would I rather have both Matsui and Damon instead of Holliday? Absolutely. I'd rather sign Matsui for 5-6 million [look at Abreu and Dunn's contract], let Damon walk, and use the money for another starting pitcher.