Actually, I will be utterly shocked if this guy does anything when it counts.
Look, being on the receiving end of two different seasons of post-season excellence, I know how good Schilling is, or can be, when it counts. There is one thing he can't get past. He is old. His fastball doesn't have the same pop as it used to. He doesn't have the same break on his pitches. It happens to all of them. What makes baseball so hard is the repetition needed for excellence. As players age, they also lose that ability. Some lose it gradually, some suddenly. They all lose it though.
These aren't cream puffs in the playoffs he will face. He will most likely face an Guardians, Tigers, or Angels lineup. He has no chance of dominance anymore. Neither does Mussina, or Clemens. You hope for a good game, but in your gut, do you really expect one?
From our two teams, the only pitchers who can throw a lights out game are Beckett, Matsuzaka, Wang, and Hughes. Pettitte will keep you in the game, and so will Wakefield if his knuckler is fluttering. You hope that Schilling, Clemens and Mussina's bodies go back in time for a few hours. Don't hold your breath though.
This isn't a rip on Schilling per se. Any pitcher that starts pushing 40 and even higher, you keep your fingers crossed.