Seriously Jacko, get off this kid's jock. He may turn out to be something, or he may be nothing. The majority of prospects turn out to be average players. If you can get an All-Star player who is a Gold Glover at his position at your current weak spot, you do it. The kid comes out, pulls his hamstring, and is out until September. Teixera can be a huge difference maker.
Now, I'm not saying that this deal WILL happen. To dismiss this out of hand, though is crazy. I am of the firm belief that you make a run to win today if you have the horses. I've heard you say you wouldn't trade this kid for anyone outside of Santana, Halliday, etc.
I couldn't stop laughing. At his best, if everything goes right, he MAY end up somewhere around that class of pitcher. More than likely he won't.
Can he be something special? Of course. Will he be? Maybe, I'll even give you probably. Is he worth a bona-fide All-Star today for you to make a run? I would say that you would have to entertain the idea, considering that he is injured, and if Arod leaves, it could be a couple of years before we unseat the Sox at the top of the AL East. I mean without Arod, just where does our offense come from? Jeter batting cleanup?