2010 was a broken foot. The hairline fracture was in a spot where it would be hard to heal without surgery regardless if he played. They let him play because it was not a weight bearing bone. If he could tolerate the pain, he couldn't damage it any worse. It turned out to be too painful to play through. He didn't damage it or aggravate it. It was just too painful to play through. That was a broke bone. This is not and as long as there is not too much discomfort he can play. Everyone treats these guys like they are eggs that need to be perfect. If you are going to play 150+ games a year, you are going to get dinged. This is a ding, not a career ending injury.He'll be putting on a Laser Show within a week. If you DL him, this team will go right in the tank with or without Ciraciao, and it would stay on track until Pedroia came back and got his timing back.