Chalk one up on the overrated tally. He's a great player, yes, but I think people are giving him way too much credit. Look at his stats, mediocre. Plus he also has an attitude, not towards teammates, but towards baseball in general.
I've hated him ever since his "screw stolen bases and singles, I want to hit home runs" quote. He said it I think two years ago and has pissed me off ever since.