Jump to content
Talk Sox
  • Create Account

Recommended Posts

Posted
It wasnt pretty, but congratulations Derek Jeter on a meaningless milestone. 2000 hits by 31 yrs old, certainly one of the 500 best....

I fixed your post for you. And moved it to the correct forum.

Posted

did arod really say that or was that his team of image consultants that came up with that quote?

 

congrads to derek for his 2000 hit

Posted
I don't know if I'd call it meaningless. It's not 3,000, but still, 2,000 is a lot of hits.

There are 239 players with 2,000 hits. It's not an exclusive club.

Posted
Not exclusive, but not meaningless either. Congrats to Jeter.

Well he joins an exclusive group of Yankees who have done it in pinstripes: the Babe, Lou Gehrig, Joe D, Bernie, Mattingly, Mickey Mantle & Yogi Berra.

Posted
Well he joins an exclusive group of Yankees who have done it in pinstripes: the Babe, Lou Gehrig, Joe D, Bernie, Mattingly, Mickey Mantle & Yogi Berra.

So it's exclusive in the spectrum of Yankees, but not MLB in general.

Posted
Yea, but the next next youngest would have, so he still can

He still can sure, but I doubt he'll get 1000 more hits in his career. Even if he plays like 10 more years, he'd just barely miss because you have to think he only have a limited number of truly productive years left in him.

Posted
He still can sure, but I doubt he'll get 1000 more hits in his career. Even if he plays like 10 more years, he'd just barely miss because you have to think he only have a limited number of truly productive years left in him.

well if he plays 10 more years, then he'll get 3,000. But I don't see him playing till hes 42, or even maybe 37;38 at that, thats why I'm not sure, but I do think he can pass gehrig for the Yankees all time(I think its like 2722)

Posted
well if he plays 10 more years, then he'll get 3,000. But I don't see him playing till hes 42, or even maybe 37;38 at that, thats why I'm not sure, but I do think he can pass gehrig for the Yankees all time(I think its like 2722)

Hmm I think he has a good shot to pass Gehrig, but I think 3000 is a bit out there.

Posted

Jeter is thirty-two, so if he plays until he is thirty-eight, we'll say..

 

He'll need to average about 167 hits a season. So far in his career he has averaged 206 a season. I think he could go it.

Posted
Point?
The point is that being the youngest Yankee to get to 2,000 is not an indicator of future milestones, because no Yankee ever got to 3,000.
Posted
The point is that being the youngest Yankee to get to 2,000 is not an indicator of future milestones, because no Yankee ever got to 3,000.
but..being the youngest Yankee means he got to the milestone faster than anyone else who was not able to reach 3,000 and that he is now in the best position of any other yankee player ever to get to 3,000 becuase he hit rate is highest.
Posted
but..being the youngest Yankee means he got to the milestone faster than anyone else who was not able to reach 3,000 and that he is now in the best position of any other yankee player ever to get to 3,000 becuase he hit rate is highest.
I can't argu that, but it would mean much more if another Yankee had gotten to 3,000 hits.
Posted
but..being the youngest Yankee means he got to the milestone faster than anyone else who was not able to reach 3,000 and that he is now in the best position of any other yankee player ever to get to 3,000 becuase he hit rate is highest.

Agreed, at the end of the day it comes down to health and how long the player wants to play. Look at Lou Gehrig. He would have gotten to 3000 hits. Don Mattingly finished with only 2153 hits. If he doesnt have that cronic back injury who knows how many hits he gets.

Jeter has been healthy for most of his entire career, if he stays healthy and plays untill hes 38 or 39 I think he gets there.

Posted
Agreed, at the end of the day it comes down to health and how long the player wants to play. Look at Lou Gehrig. He would have gotten to 3000 hits. Don Mattingly finished with only 2153 hits. If he doesnt have that cronic back injury who knows how many hits he gets.

Jeter has been healthy for most of his entire career, if he stays healthy and plays untill hes 38 or 39 I think he gets there.

With Jeter there are some additional considerations beyond his health. As a SS will he be able to hold down the SS position until age 37 or 38. If he ages out of the position, does he move to 3rd? ARod is already there. Do they move him 1B? He is a good offensive player, but he doesn't have the kind of pop that you look for from a first baseman. He has always been a top of the order hitter, partly because of his speed. Will he be a viable top of the order hitter at 38? He doesn't have middle of the order pop.
Posted
Agreed, at the end of the day it comes down to health and how long the player wants to play. Look at Lou Gehrig. He would have gotten to 3000 hits. Don Mattingly finished with only 2153 hits. If he doesnt have that cronic back injury who knows how many hits he gets.

Jeter has been healthy for most of his entire career, if he stays healthy and plays untill hes 38 or 39 I think he gets there.

Well Jeter is a shortstop, I doubt he can productively hold down that spot until 38 or 39, so they'll have to move him. But where would they move him. As has been noted, A-Rod holds down 3rd base, and I'm not sure Jeter could play 1st. He could DH, but at 38 will he really have enough pop left in the bat to justify that spot?

Posted
If that was to happen, he could always Ruben Sierra or Frank Thomas it, move to DH/Spot Fielder, I'm sure Bernie and Giambi will have well passed on their playing days by then
Posted
Well Jeter is a shortstop, I doubt he can productively hold down that spot until 38 or 39, so they'll have to move him. But where would they move him. As has been noted, A-Rod holds down 3rd base, and I'm not sure Jeter could play 1st. He could DH, but at 38 will he really have enough pop left in the bat to justify that spot?

idk, Bernie is(kinda) holding the fort even now, at 37, hes on track for maybe 130-150(?) Hits, and his lifetime average is 185, so with Jeters being 206, even a quarter of a fall off would still on register for a nessisary, say, 6,7 more years. Health Pending

Posted
With Jeter there are some additional considerations beyond his health. As a SS will he be able to hold down the SS position until age 37 or 38. If he ages out of the position, does he move to 3rd? ARod is already there. Do they move him 1B? He is a good offensive player, but he doesn't have the kind of pop that you look for from a first baseman. He has always been a top of the order hitter, partly because of his speed. Will he be a viable top of the order hitter at 38? He doesn't have middle of the order pop.

You bring up some good points. I look at Jeter and I think he can be a productive player at SS for awhile. For arguments sake lets say his defensive skills erode at age 36. The Yankees can then maybe split him at 1B and DH almost like they do with Bernie right now(except he plays the OF and Bernie really doesnt have the pop for a corner OF anyway.). Maybe by that time you move A-Rod back to SS and move Jeter to 3rd. There are alot of options. I heard this somewhere and I'm gonna have to do the math but if he gets 150 hits per year untill hes 38 he will get to 3000 hits. IMO he can get that done.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
The Talk Sox Caretaker Fund
The Talk Sox Caretaker Fund

You all care about this site. The next step is caring for it. We’re asking you to caretake this site so it can remain the premier Red Sox community on the internet.

×
×
  • Create New...