Agree, about different seasons, I don't go by WAR. Never have. I cant see 42+ HRS, a difference in only 5-6 wins. You have to go by games played, at the moment of playing. WAR sounds too generalization, and lazy to me.
Reason I'm not a WAR person is that Outs in Baseball produces runs. And that what Baseball is really all about, Runs.
WAR doesn't give me the situation.
Quick situation for me, that would never show up in WAR...
Runner at third and 1st 1 out, tie game....Batter hits it to SS, but busts his ass to 1st and beats it out, Run Scores, win that game by 1 run. Does that show? Its a Fielders Choice, Outs were made. Yet you won.