I'm an old school guy with no analytics....
I was always told you put your best hitter in 3 spot. At the high school level, that was usually your shortstop or a pitcher, your best all around athlete. Probably the quarterback on the football team that's dating the head cheerleader (how am I doing Kimmi?). Hits for high average and has power. Basically .333 guy with 30 home runs.
Your best power guy batted clean up. In high school, maybe your catcher or the corner infield guy. Not as athletic as the #3 hitter. Hits .300 with 40 homers. Usually dates a pretty girl with no athletic background. Basically your faithful girl that comes to all the games. A church goer.
You put your best speed guy, probably playing center field, leading off. Great contact hitter. In high school, he's probably hitting well over .400 with 30 steals in 30 games. His girl friend is little bit on the wild side. She's an athlete.
Your second hitter is patient at the plate, always playing the game the right way. He maybe a lefty but if a righty, he hits to opposite field often. He sacrifices his batting average a little for the good of the team, bunting and moving runners over. He dates a sweet girl that volunteers quite a bit for local charities.
Your #5 hitter hits for power but does not make contact as often as the clean up hitter. He maybe a DH or RF on a high school team. Hits .280 and 35 home runs. He dates a smart girl who will make a good wife.
That's my top 5 slots and I'm sticking to it no matter what Kimmi says.