One last beat down on a dead horse.
I like to praise or critique trades/signings at the time of the transaction. It's always easy to look back and support your decision based on what transpires afterwards.
Clay B.....even if Clay was healthy and pitching well for the Phillies, I still would think the decision to trade him was the right one. Trade has to be fair for both sides. Phillies got a pitcher with ton of upside and Sox got rid of $13.5M contract.
Clay had two things going against him and one was out of his control. His $13.5M price did him no favors for one but he mainly got caught up in Sox wanting to go below the luxury tax limit. Now front office can say whatever it wants, but I think THAT had lot to do with it. Had our payroll sat at $150M, I'd say keep him. No sweat. Sox would have kept him too.
Price....There was simply not much available as far as top of the line pitching was concerned. Again, it was something DD had to do. Did we overpay? Perhaps but not knowing what the going price was DD was not going to take any chances and get beaten out by another offer. It's unfortunate $31M per year sticks out like a sore thumb but it is what it is. No chance we win the division without him last year. Can we have it done cheaper? Perhaps but it's all Monday am quarterbacking to me.
Kimbrel....this one hurts but it was our inability to have a healthy closer at the time that forced DD to make this move. Not only did it take Kimbrel, but we also had to trade for Ziegler and convert Kelly in a relief role to accomplish what we did. With emergence of some arms in the pen, it's pretty certain we will not resign him after 2018. As Moon said, was it worth paying FA price AND prospects for his 3 years of service? I'd say yes only if we win the world series. BUT again, this was a move DD thought he had to make in order for us to become a contender for 2016. He was right, even though we may have overpaid.
Pomeranz....again, inconsistencies from Kelly, E Rod and Clay B forced this trade. I still think it was the correct move. The possibility exists for Espinoza to become a stud pitcher and Pomeranz to be mediocre pitcher for 2 1/2 years of service. Did we overpay? Probably. But DD was not going to sit idle and watch the team implode. As it turned out, Pom did not help the Sox but again that's after the fact.
Sale.....no brainer. Emergence of Devers probably made trading away Moncada easier. Signing Groome probably made trading away Kopech more palpable. Finally a team friendly 3 year contract. Really enhances our chances of 'going for it'.
It will be interesting to see what's needed for Sox at trade deadline and what's available. I would think Groome, Devers and Travis are untouchable for a half year rental if we decide to make a move.