Jump to content
Talk Sox
  • Create Account

notin

Old-Timey Member
 View Profile  See their activity

  • Posts

    55,117

  • Joined

  • Last visited

  • Days Won

    54

 Content Type 

Profiles

Boston Red Sox Videos

2026 Boston Red Sox Top Prospects Ranking

Boston Red Sox Free Agent & Trade Rumors, Notes, & Tidbits

Guides & Resources

2025 Boston Red Sox Draft Pick Tracker

News

2026 Boston Red Sox Draft Tracker: Picks & Bonuses

Forums

Blogs

Events

Store

Downloads

Gallery

Everything posted by notin

  1. notin
    You might be putting words in Cora’s mouth. Did he avoid asking Devers because he didn’t think Devers could play first? Or because he didn’t want to ask Devers to make another change after the first time went so awkwardly?
  2. notin
    If his value is not quantifiable, why is he so important? Is it because he won a ring after inheriting a two-time defending AL East champion? And then proceeded to maintain .500 baseball for 6 years? Is his value in Henry still liking him? The same John Henry who didn’t want to keep Mookie? You’re expressing plenty of dedication to a man who has guided the Sox to a 453-439 record since 2018. It’s easy to list off bad moves and blame injuries - and I agree those things dont help. But they’re not unique to Boston, either. And stop copping out with “you just don’t like Cora.” I don’t think he is a good MLB manager. That’s hardly a condemnation. I don’t think I’d be a good one either, and I certainly don’t hate myself for it. So why the dedication?
  3. notin
    I go the opposite. I hated the idea of trading him, but they seemed to get a decent return (one BA Top 100 SP, a first round pick, and a lottery ticket) for getting SF to take the entire contract. Granted, they were probably helped by the Giants’ inability to attract any major free agent…
  4. notin
    Just like you blaming it on injured pitchers who threw only 24 fewer IP, I suppose…
  5. notin
    You’re right. All you did was mention it. After all, it was on a laundry list of things you pointed out that worked against Cora. But you also, by saying maybe this roster isn’t as good as we thought, introduced the dangerous notion that “whatever goes wrong, it isn’t Cora.” (And I limited you to introducing the idea. Don’t run with that.) So I will again ask a simple question - what does Cora bring to the table?
  6. notin
    Sale, Price, ERod and Porcello combined for 655 IP in 2018. That same 4 combined for 631 IP in 2019. Thats not some huge difference. 6 IP per pitcher. One start. They had Eovaldi for a full year in 2019, and he barely pitched. Still he gave them more innings than he did in 2018 since he was only there for 2 months. I didn’t count him because it was fever going to be fair…
  7. notin
    The downfall started in 2019, when they lost 24 more games that the season previous. Betts and Sale were both on that team. And don’t accuse me of exaggerating when you brought the Sale trade up in the first place. Sale was on the roster from 2019-2023, and how much did he help during that 5 season stretch?
  8. notin
    Let’s not completely overlook Bregman’s highest AAV in team history contract that allowed him to control his own free agency. It’s a fairly nice enticement. Since 2018, the Sox are barely over .500 under Cora (and that didn’t count 2020, as he was not here). That includes his 2019 season, in which the team won 24 fewer games than the year before (second largest difference in team history). If the roster was a great one in 2018, what made it a .500-ish roster in 2019? What exactly does Cora bring to the table that gives his fanbase such dedication?
  9. notin
    Who did it before Cora? Cora has been around through 4 CBOs. At what point do we stop blaming everyone else around him and look at him? Or are you trying to argue that everyone else everywhere in the organization are the incompetent ones and Cora is just the victim here? And can we stop blaming the downfall of the organization on the Sale trade, as if no other team has made trades that didn’t work out? Wouldn’t the Yankees have been much better off holding on to Fitts and Weissert over the nothing they got from Verdugo?
  10. notin
    More likely, Cora is vastly overvalued. Hes the common link in a long chain of mediocrity. Even his supporters defend him with “but he can win if you give him a roster anyone can win with,” as if meeting expectations is some sort of super power. He’s been around almost as long as Francona, with nowhere near the track record. Heck his predecessor was fired for being more successful (and Cora may have had a hand in that as well)…
  11. notin
    Right! Anything but play first base, you mean!!
  12. notin
    And they want to run this like a Tampa Rays forum. Even if it means packaging mvp with dgalehouse’s contract to make it happen…
  13. notin
    Or more often with someone already on 2b?
  14. notin
    I’m not worried about Mayer. He’s been slow adjusting but doing well. His biggest obstacle will be Cora benching him against LHP during a lost season…
  15. notin
    McLain has a polished .631 OPS / 70 OPS+ this year. Mayer has a .690 OPS / 89 OPS+, but it’s very unpolished. The kids are fine. The Sox already white-flagged the season. Bring up Campbell, Harrison and the Password. Sell off Duran, Chapman, Wilson and maybe Refsnyder. And maybe fire Cora and look forward to 2026…
  16. notin
    Cora bailed on the entire situation at the word go…
  17. notin
    Yoshida could have been activated already if not for some questionable management and selfish teammates. The guy was a DH all through ST and then got injured? Im seriously questioning Casas’ worth. He is going to miss most of 2024 and 2025 because he injured himself 1) seining a bat and 2) running to first. Whats 2026 hold? He going to miss next year because he hurt himself fielding a ground ball? I’d trade him in a second if I thought he had any value (and I had a job that allowed me to do so). Most likely, he’s a non-tender candidate.
  18. notin
    That’s a bit presumptuous. Could any manager have won with those rosters? No one thought the 2025 roster was a .500 team in March. And essentially if his defense is, your defense boils down Cora essentially adding nothing. “Give him a .500 roster and he finishes .500.” Yeah, manager…
  19. notin
    Small samples but it is obvious what happened. i dont get why they didn’t wait until July 31st. Devers was probably being a complete tool, but he didn’t let it affect his hitting. Did Devers give some sort of deadline? Did SF? So now Breslow has to pretend to be a buyer for 6 weeks while the offense flounders and no one will sell him the replace he wants. (Why is Breslow ignoring that Toro stopped hitting, for example?)
  20. notin
    Jhostnyxon “The Password” Garcia was added to the 40 man roster last November..,
  21. notin
    Depends what they get for him…
  22. notin
    BTV says Duran for Painter is equal value, but Philly says Painter is untouchable
  23. notin
    Then maybe stop picking him up by his tail…
  24. notin
    I listed him among them. I think Duran, Chapman, Wilson and, if healthy, Hicks…
  25. notin
    The 2005 Astros were 37-44 after 81 games en route to losing the 2005 WS to the White Sox. The 2019 Nationals were 41-40 after 81 games...
×
×
  • Create New...