And the risk of watching Anthony reach free agency at 27 was worth all these deals combined.
It’s not a “league wide fad;” it’s the new economic reality. And yes, occasionally it doesn’t work out. Can’t the same be saud for free agents?
The complaints around this “fad” all revolve around who else the Sox could have signed instead. But those players are ALWAYS on the wrong side of 30 and watching their skills fade at various rates. And Ive never once heard anyone say “thank God we signed David Price instead of extending Mookie Betts.” If you’re going to play in that arena, there are two sides. Also Bregman has a 103 OPS+ this year. He’s basically another Yoshida - the guy everyone wants to dump. Is that really the missing piece? The big difference is Yoshida has only one more year; Bregman cost twice as much per year snd is signed for 4 more years. Did the Sox really miss out here?
None of these Sox deals really add up to much. Campbell’s AAV is high end utility infielder money. As a former Minor League Player of the Year and MLB Rookie of the Month, I think he can at least be a utility infielder. Bello was good last year (9th in the AL in ERA), but struggled down the stretch and early tjis year. He was never a top prospect, but he really was establishing himself after a good 2023. When is a player “established”? If you wait too long, many players (re: agents) know they can make more money and fewer years in arbitration.
Think of it this way - Anthony’s injury history is not that significant. While it happened twice in MLB (hardly trailblazing), he really never got hurt on the minors playing the same game. If he reaches free agency at 27, he could easily make command money than all of these extensions combined. Think Boston pays it then?
Fans want the team to spend more, but then don’t like it when they do…