Is that true?
Hard to compare and evaluate those deals, but using the FV assigned by Fangraphs, the two prospects given up by the Yankees totaled 95. In order to top that offer, the Red Sox would have had to trade either Downs or Casas along with Gilberto Jimenez. To equal that offer, the Sox could have kept Jimenez and offered one of Duran, Houck, or Dalbec.
Of course, this really isn’t proper use of Future Value. Using BTV, Alcantara and Vizcaino are roughly equal to dealing Seabold and Song.
Vastly different comparison methods, but neither really says the Yankees didn’t give up much compared to what the Sox would have had to give up.,.