Again, I don't get giddy over 7-11 games stretches.
I said our 5th starter is a mess, but I also said we need a solid #2. It's just that our current # is not a "mess." I just think I'd feel much better calling Bello & Dobbins my 3-4's and Gio my 5th.
I am optimistic, but excuse me if I'm not giddy over Gio, either. Hell, I'm not convinced Dobbins & Bello are for real, just yet. I have no reason to think they will crash and burn, but just look at the Houck example, last season and to start this season. The possibility is still out there, even for an optimist.
I don't think Toro is better than Casas, either. Ok, better than a teenie tiny, hand-selected sample size for both of them, but I'm not buying. I'm not dissing Toro or Romy. I love what they have done, but even an optimist has to doubt this continuing. I'd bet my house on Casas having a better OPS from 2026 onwards than Romy or Toro. He's a better hitter. I don't even see a debate on this. Again, I'm fine with you thinking this, but we differ on recency sample size values as predictors of what will be going forward.
Story to 2B does fix the issue, but Bregman may not be back until August, so we have a .475 DHam at 2B and a AAAA Eaton there, now. The return of Abreu is great news, but he doesn't play 2B or 1B, and I'm not for moving Rafaela to 2B, either. He will likely replace .074 Anthony, but again, I'm not projecting Anthony to hit .074, if he keeps playing FT.
I'm optimistic about our chances to make the playoffs. I think the rest of the AL sucks or is mediocre with as many or more issues as we have. My point is our odds got worse with the Devers trade- not better. I've never said our hopes were extinguished.
You seem to be implying our odds are the same, because our pitching is doing great. Well, they are not doing great because Devers is gone. Our offense is struggling, even as we eek out win after win. I'm not a pessimist to worry how long that can and will continue.
Here's a bright angle for you and may help reaffirm my optimism in your eyes:
Record in one run games:
6-17 before June 11.
3-0 June 11 and after
(We've also gone 4-0 in 2 run wins since June 10th)
Last 8 games:
20 runs scored/ 17 runs allowed and a 7-1 record!