It's hard to know if Bregman's numbers would be better had he came back to BOS, or what his effect would have been on Anthony and other player's numbers.
I think it's fair to bring up how other highly winter-discussed players are doing so far, if we are using the bad stats of players we did add as a way to criticize Brez & Co.
I, for one am holding back being highly critical of Brez for adding Durbin, when many of the players I suggested we add are crapping themselves at big money levels. Sure, some of my suggested additions are doing well, but some of Brez's adds are too (Contreras, Suarez & Samaniego.)
How many of us wanted us to move on from Wong (.712?)
How many did not trust counting on young arms to fill key roles? While Watson has sucked and Oviedo is on the 60, Early, Tolle, Bennet & Samaniego have helped us in many of our 13 wins.
As bad as we have looked, this year, one thing some of us pointed out last winter has rung true: the rest of the AL teams have serious issues, too. Only 2 AL teams are more than 2 games above .500, (21-11 NYY & 19-12 TBR) and I'm not sure the Rays even make the playoffs this year.
Our best hopes might lie with us having less weaknesses than 10 other AL teams. Currently, 11 teams are withing 4 games of each other and between 17-15 (.531) and 13-19 (.406.)
The current 5th best AL team is 16-16 (TEX.) Whodathunk the Rays (19-12) A's (17-15) Guardians (17-16) & TEX (16-16) would be the other 4 playoff teams with NYY at about the 20% mark of the season? My guess is several, if not all won't make the playoffs.
The next 4 teams all looked more promising in March:
16-17 SEA & DET
15-17 TOR & BAL
These 4 could easily replace the 4 I listed.
The Sox are 2 GB TOR & BAL. They are 2.5 GB SEA & DET. They are 3 GM the last WC slot. Yes, it's way too early to talk WC slot and with 6 other teams between us and Texas, it might be harder than it looks, but all of these teams will go through some tough stretches. We might just need to limit any more like we just went through.
We've won 4 of 6 vs BAL, TOR & HOU. Maybe we can keep this going, despite 4 of our 5 SP'ers being on the IL (Crochet, Gray, Oviedo) or sucking (Bello.)