softy started with Crisp > "punch and Judy" Jacoby.
I've always been fine with JBJ as our CF'er, even with poor D, and I liked him more than Ellsbury, too.
I've been defending his bat a lot, which make it seem like I feel he needs to hit to keep playing, which I don't agree with, but I do feel his offense has been good enough to play despite the defense for over 3 years now.
Yes, he slumps. Yes, his slumps can be long and horrific.
Overall, he does good enough on offense.
If anyone thinks it's 50-50 when considering his defense in the equation, his base running should tilt to playing him FT.