So, if you divide the playoff teams into two groups: the better half vs the worse half, you'd call a 55% to 45% split a "crap shoot?"
How about a 60-40 split?
A 2 to 1 split?
Well, 78% have won the WS in the last 9 years. Maybe it used to be somewhat random, but it is not anymore.
Even more convincing, about the last 9 seasons, 4 of the 9 WS winners were the best record teams. Total randomness would predict about 1.
Okay,maybe you can claim "small sample size." Something I have used often, but times have changed. The rich have gotten obscenely richer and better.