Yes, I know what hindsight means, and I know you hated the Kike signing and Bloom hiring from day one.
It's not hindsight in the general sense it is used, but you know damn well, you would not be mentioning the money saved by trading Beni to offset Kike and Kike vs Holt had Kike been hitting .850. Just because you knew he wouldn't hit .850 beforehand does not mean you didn't cherry pick the comp in hindsight.
Plus, the money Kike cost does not match up with the money saved on the Beni deal, even if you subtract Holt's contract from his.
A closer comp is Renfroe, since he has 2 years of control and cost about what the difference was on the Beni deal. Another similar money comp would be Sawamura, but the positions are way different.
Perhaps using Marwin would make your case stronger.
Beni for Marwin and the 5 players.