I don't think sending him down is giving up, but it's certainly not a vote of confidence. (I do see it as a way to work out something with his swing that is bothering him.)
I'm not saying option 1 is the best choice, either. I do think we need to try to improve our offense, and right now, McGuire is one of our best hitters, and he has been since last August.
Best Sox OPS since 8/1/22:
.892 McGuire
.889 Story
.829 Dugo
.800 Bogey
.769 Turner
.743 JD
.716 Dalbec
.784 Refsnyder