I doubt we give up on McGuire, so quickly. He has several years of team control, and Hickey is a couple years away.
I think McGuire has been playing hurt, some. He missed some starts, I think would have been his, earlier this year.
On the numbers with pitchers, one has to realize who each has caught way more than the other and adjust, accordingly.
Also, the head to head match-ups are pretty close to even:
(Note: McGuire has caught about 60% of all PAs Against- a 3:2 ratio)
OPS Against with each catcher:
** Note the unbalanced PAs against
Houck
.692 Wong (263 PAs) **
.727 McGuire (22)
Sale
.633 Wong (185) **
1.061 McGuire (64 mostly early in the season)
Bello (I'm counting this even)
.695 Wong (142)
.696 McGuire (142)
Paxton
.631 Wong (130) **
.683 McGuire (26)
Whitlock
.810 Wong (110)
.714 McGuire (62)
Crawford
.815 Wong (109)
.472 McGuire (78)
Winckowski
.656 Wong (110)
.595 McGuire (62)
Pivetta
.646 Wong (126)
.904 McGuire (124)
Kluber
.918 Wong (51)
.982 McGuire (206)**
_________________
Jansen
.722 Wong (79)
.328 McGuire (31)
Martin
.581 Wong (66)
.401 McGuire (26)
When not counting massive unbalanced sample size, McGuire actually has done better or the same with more pitchers than Wong, especially the younger ones (Bello, Crawford and Wink). McGuire 5-1
If you count the unbalanced samples: Wong 5- McGuire 5
(If Sale and Kulber don't pitch the rest of the season, it's 5-3 McGuire.)
This is not meant to disparage Wong. He's done a great job behind the plate. There was an expected learning curve, early in the season, as we added so many new pitchers, and Wong and McGuire had very little history with any pitchers on the staff.