Outside of Porcello, the starters' current ERAs are roughly 2 runs higher than their career ERAs. Their current ERAs are also significantly higher than their most recent 3 year averages, 2 year averages, and last year's ERAs. In other words, we are talking about career worst ERAs, by substantial margins, for 4 of our 5 starters. That is enigmatic, especially considering their FIPs and xFIPs. It has to get better.
Some of you are saying that you saw this coming before the season started, but you couldn't have foreseen all of them to be underperforming to the extent that they are underperforming. Some of you agree that it will get better, but not enough for this team to contend. If these guys were pitching at their career levels, or at last year's level, as I'm sure the FO was banking on, the picture would look a lot different.