It should be 2 games worse, which is not far worse. Call it an enigma if you want, which clearly you want, but not because you really think that it's an enigma. The real enigma is still why the offense is not hitting and scoring runs.
I am not denying that we have been fortunate in terms of run differential, not to mention that many of those runs were unearned, but Pythagorean W-L and run differential will become more significant as the season wears on.