Well, yes and no. But baseball isn't like basketball or other sports. In basketball, defensive specialists don't have to shoot; in baseball, he has to hit--it's not a 'bonus'. Sure, if he doesn't make that catch last night, it's a one-run game. But if he had gotten a hit or two earlier, that catch wouldn't have mattered. Of course as a fan, I'd much rather watch these spectacular catches than a weak single to the opposite field--that's why I have always liked JBJ. But as far as winning games is concerned, the hit he prevents every three games or so is less valuable than, say, the two hits an average MLB hitter could have gotten at the plate during the same period.