Ease up, man. I'm just jabbering like you. I'm not trying to tell you what to say, I'm just chucking my own thoughts into the mix. That question was largely a rhetorical one.
The crapshoot is realer than real now. Just ask the Dodgers. 3 years in a row of winning 100+ and watching the Series on TV, 3 years in a row of teams with under 90 wins in the Series.
Arizona not only made it with 84 wins last year, they had a minus run differential in the regular season. That's ridiculous. But it's what MLB wants, apparently.
My recollection is that we were not in bad shape injury-wise at the 2023 deadline.
If you don't believe in the crapshoot after watching the 2023 postseason I don't know what you need LOL
You're certainly not the only one who blames Cora for the Kike fiasco.
I'm a Cora fan so I'm biased, but I mostly blame Bloom for it. Bloom is the guy who signed Story, and Kike, and Mondesi, and could have acquired Andrus, or Iglesias.
As it turned out, sure, but who knows how much of the team's collapse was a mental one due to the lack of help/lack of commitment shown by Bloom? I believe in some of the intangibles stuff.
The bottom line is the 2023 team was 2-3 out of the playoffs at the deadline. Is that out of it?
Conversely, a couple of good acquisitions might have put the 2023 team in the playoffs.
The expansion of the playoff field has added a lot of uncertainty to the deadline approach. Last year a team with 84 wins made it to the World Series, so arguably if you're around .500 at the deadline you still have a shot, depending on your specific circumstances.
Agreed. The only thing I can say at this point is that Breslow shows signs of being a sharper and more decisive move-maker than Bloom, and that's an encouraging thing.
You're making a pretty strange argument. He "succeeded" in unloading Kike and acquiring Urias, a couple of very minor moves, when there were much more significant moves that could have been made. Saying he did nothing is a fair description.
To each their own, for me it's just a little depressing to hear that when the team has gotten off to a much better start than one would have expected given the roster and the injuries.
It still doesn't mean Betts would be "wasted" on the Sox. That's a ridiculous statement on its face. And if they had Betts, they would likely have done some things differently. Butterfly effect and all that.
He also said "the best team for him to be on was and is the Dodgers."
Actually, I'm not even 100% sure what that's supposed to mean, so I may have misinterpreted.
If you want to throw out the champ for a pandemic year, we should probably throw out all the champs for the World War years too. Plenty of guys were not playing baseball those years for good reason too...
1) 2020 was not the first season with a reduced number of regular season games - not by a long shot.
2) The World Series champion is decided by the playoffs, not by the regular season.
3) We all know we'd be singing a different tune if the Sox won it in 2020.
Gratuitous literary reference:
Reading some of Max's posts is like reading Kafka. The individual sentences seem to make perfect sense, but the narrative as a whole makes less and less sense as you go on.
Also, any attempts to throw out 2020 are ********. They did the best they could in the face of a pandemic, and the playoffs were totally legit. The Dodgers and Rays were the 2 best teams at the time. Last year's matchup of the Rangers and Diamondbacks was less legit than the 2020 matchup.