Kimmi, one of the all-time classic examples of why both the save stat and the hold stat should be abolished came in a game that Sox fans all know and love - Game 5 of the 2004 ALCS.
As we all remember with joy, Joe Torre elected to let Tom Gordon start the 8th with the Yanks leading 4-2. Gordon gave up the home run to Papi. Torre didn't budge. Gordon gave up a walk to Millar and a single to Nixon, moving pinch runner Roberts to third. Torre finally trudged out to the mound and removed Gordon for Rivera. Rivera gave up a game-tying sac fly to Varitek, then retired the side. He also pitched a scoreless ninth, raising the question of why Torre didn't have him start the 8th.
At the end of the day, Gordon's stat line shows 2 runs allowed in 0.2 innings. Rivera's shows 0 runs allowed in 2 innings.
Gordon was credited with a hold. Rivera was charged with a blown save.