I think you're being deliberately obtuse. Included in that 55% are obvious mismatches, like it will be this year when the Cubs play the NL wild card. That series could be played in Japan and the Cubs would still be at a huge advantage.
I think the idea is that the L-R thing can be crucial when it does arise in those late and close situations.
Pinch hitters are sometimes available and sometimes a complete non-issue - it could be the 3-4-5 hitters we're talking about.
Kimbrel is a big concern right now, he has to be. 6 walks in his last 3 outings, which is equal to the number of outs he recorded. That's scary business.
As it says, there's no clear-cut definition and it's up to the judgment of the voter. If you think it should simply go to the best player that's your prerogative.
Very unfair. He was brought in with the bases loaded and made one bad pitch to a left-handed power hitter in a park built for left-handed power hitters. Other than that, he's has been doing a great job from the pen.
Those stats would need to be stratified based on how big the difference between the 2 teams in W-L record.
What I'm really interested in is how much does HFA impact the outcome when the regular season difference between the 2 teams is small.
I disagree. Porcello's W-L record is a product of 2 things:
1) Excellent pitching.
2) Luck - almost 7 runs of support per game.
No, you can't penalize him for the run support, but you can't reward him for it either. You have to compare the quality of his pitching against Kluber & Sale & leave the W-L out of it.
Yeah, the only thing that's concerning is that this is the second time, the other being on August 9, that he's totally lost the ability to throw strikes. He walked 4 in the other game.
Nope. That was his first game, but not his all-important first home game. His first home game was 8 IP/4 ER, for a horrible 4.50 ERA, and a no-decision. He didn't step up in that vital contest. I'm surprised nobody remembers.
C'mon Slash, you're not being reasonable at all. This reminds me of when Pumpsie Green used to say the same thing about Lester.
Price has 225 IP, an ERA+ of 113, a K/BB of 4.77, a bWAR of 2.9.
Saying he has pitched like a #2 is fair.