Pitching and pitching strategy cannot be as bad as you make it out to be, jung.
Even with the Manfred Missile, major league teams are only averaging 4.5 earned runs a game.
Unless you want to credit this fact to the hitters not being very good either (which I suspect is exactly what you want to do).
The idea of trading a solid young everyday player for a reliever makes me gag. The fact that said reliever is having a horrible season doesn't help, of course...
Computers are there to crank out data, but humans still have to make the decisions, for better or worse.
With Dave Dombrowski and Tony Larussa, I think we've still got a little old school thinking going on, for better or worse.
Which shows the limited value of such simulations.
Would anyone in their right mind trade Benintendi for Diaz (plus $11.3 million more of theoretical trade value) right now?
I'm sure Dave Dombrowski would have a good laugh at the idea.