I think the Yanks are recovering most of Ellsbury's pay through insurance as long as he 'can't play'. So that significantly reduces their financial incentive to move him.
I'm sure there was debate.
I think if there was no extension and Sale went out and had a strong season, he would be looking at something like $200 million in free agency.
What he agreed to was about $128 million, in present value dollars, based on the calcs done for his AAV.
It all keeps coming back to how the problems in his arm could be missed in a high-tech medical exam.
I caution against reading too much into any of it. Henry did approve the trade for Cashner, which was overlooked because it happened early and because he pitched like s***.
Also, I doubt that Henry disagreed with DD about everything after the WS. Maybe just about the overall philosophy DD was espousing.
And Henry certainly can't disown the Sale extension. He went on record about how they didn't want to make the same mistake they made with Lester et cetera.
John Henry is a smart man and he understands very well the balances between the short-term and long-term, and between making money and putting a team on the field that keeps fans interested.
cp, a lot of fans love the blame game, and it's not just DD who has had the finger pointed at him for this year's failures. Cora has been raked on the coals pretty good for the spring training program and other issues. A few here have called for him to be fired too. And our pitching coaches have already been canned.
Any chances the Red Sox have to contend in 2020 depend heavily on the questionable health and effectiveness of SPE. (Might as well start using an acronym for Sale, Price and Eovaldi.)
1) moon's statement was sarcasm.
2) Please see this thread I started on the topic.
https://www.talksox.com/forum/threads/19588-Are-the-playoffs-really-a-crapshoot
We know that the Red Sox are totally overhauling their pitching management, that was started before Bloom was hired.
I must point out though, that our pitching, while awful in 2019, served us pretty well in 2018, including Price, obviously.
You're a brutal man, Larry.
First of all, JD was a great signing by DD-not just the player but the contract structure.
Secondly, it was obviously an organizational decision not to go into sell mode last July.