Here's one of my little issues with the 'crapshoot' philosophy.
If you fully subscribe to the theory that every team that gets in has an equal chance:
1) Deadline deals like the acquisitions of Eovaldi, Pearce and Kinsler in 2018, or Peavy in 2013, were 'unnecessary', because we already had a playoff spot virtually clinched.
2) What's the point of a team that has clinched getting players a little rest at the end of the season to have them in better shape for the playoffs?
3) What's the point of a team that has clinched trying to get their pitching rotation properly lined up for the playoffs?