There would be some angst, with scribes and message board wizards pointing out that he threw 249 innings last year and 462 innings the last 2 years-massive totals by today's standards-and suggesting it may have caught up to him.
Here's the analysis Alex Speier did showing how the Red Sox could save $100 million over the next 3 years by re-setting. That number includes $38.5 million in reduced payroll for 2020.
The $243.5 number represents the 2019 payroll number for tax purposes.
If the Red Sox don't reset*(assumes $212 million luxury tax threshold in 2022).
Year Payroll Luxury tax Revenue sharing rebate penalty Total
2020 243.5 19.61 6 269.11
2021 243.5 18.61 9 271.11
2022 243.5 17.61 12 273.11
Total 730.5 55.83 27 813.33
If the Red Sox do reset
Year Payroll Luxury tax Revenue sharing rebate penalty Total
2020 205 0 0 205
2021 243.5 8.32 0 251.82
2022 243.5 10.83 3 257.33
Total 692 19.15 3 714.15
Fun facts:
1) This is more than double (admittedly not much more than double) the $161 million contract the Yankees gave Sabathia before the 2009 season.
2) It's almost as much as the combined $345 million contracts the Yankees gave Teixeira and Sabathia before the 2009 season.
We have no idea what the offers were last year. Maybe another team offer 3 * 17...who knows.
The Sox seem focused on trading Price. If they succeed I assume they're keeping Eovaldi.
Did we not agree that other teams were in on Eovaldi too?
And I think it's pretty obvious the way Eovaldi pitched in the 2018 postseason had a lot to do with his perceived value.
Nobody knows what his plans are. We know one thing, his decision to wait it out until free agency is probably going to put at least $100 million more in his pocket.