Buerhle wouldn't be asked to "mow them down" here. He'd be asked to eat innings as the fifth starter, something the Red Sox sorely lacked last season.
A lesson that should be learned from 2011 is that a pitcher who can eat innings is very valuable even if he's not a world-beater.
Even if we need to keep him away from the Yankees, he brings two things to the table the Sox need desperately: Good command and the ability to pitch deep into games. For a guy that would be the fifth starter and probably wouldn't make ace money, that's pretty good.
Other than that, a guy like Jeremy Guthrie fits the bill, i wonder what his status is.