Ortiz is too inconsistent for a long term contract. He also is available at a huge home town discount. I see the Sox treating him like the Yankees treat Andy Pettite now-- lots of short term incentive-laden contracts.
I agree on finding a corner infielder, but I could live with the Sox being a seller this year if it meant getting another of the elite hitters. Everyone sounds skeptical when I say trade Beltre/Vmart, but if they do and get a A-gon/Fielder type out of the deal, the team wins in the long run. The problem is that if you go down the list of guys we'd want at 1B (Votto, Cabrera, Morneau, Pujols, Agon, Texeira) are untouchable right now. Fielder is probably the only one available--and I'm skeptical about him. People have mentioned getting a replacement at 3B, but quite frankly none of the available guys will be a better combo than Vmart/Youk.
That leads me to think it might be best to sign Vmart long term, as a one year fill-in at 1B.When the big bats hit the open market in 2011, drop Ortiz, slide Vmart to DH/occasional catcher. Best case scenario Lars or Lavernway turn gold, and they don't even need to get one of those guys.