I disagree very strongly with this one. Trading away Reddick was a huge mistake, I'll give you that. But his other moves have been fine. He added considerable pitching depth to the organization with a tiny budget. He added a lot of options, some turned to busts, and some turned into quality pieces. Even after losing a high-end closer, it is still a much deeper bullpen than Theo has ever build, and the back end of the rotation is much better we ever suspected. He did not give into the pressure, and let Varitek and Wakefield go.
Scutaro has had a .680 OPS this year, and he did well on selling high on him. Lowrie has played well, but even in a healthy year, he's already been on the DL twice. With our medical staff here, I doubt he would have played more than ten games in 2012 for the Red Sox.
Cody Ross was perhaps the best signing of any GM all offseason. Youkilis was a tough trade, but I don't think he'd be hitting .300 if still with the Red Sox, it seemed like a change-of-location causeed the increase in production for him. Punto sucks.
Its across the board. Some good moves, some bad. I don't think he deserves any lower than a C or B. If the team's aces had pitching like aces, he'd be gettting so much praise for building the depth, and Ross, but they're losing so he's getting s*** on. It happens.