If you were Terry Francona, and you had the following OFers:
Bay: .900+ OPS last year, 30+ HRs, 100+ RBI. 15 million salary.
Cameron: .800+ OPS last year, 20+ HR, 80+ RBI.Elite defensively. 7.5 million salary.
JD Drew: .900+ OPS last year, 20+ HR, 60+ RBI. Elite defensively. 14 million salary.
Jacoby Ellsbury: 770+ OPS last year, 8 HR, 70 SB. Questionable defensively. League minimum salary.
Who do you realistically sit?
Oh, and by the way, "silly" is not a proper response.