I was really eager for the Yankees to execute the Santana trade. I'm sorry that they didn't.
Of course, I want the Yankees to lose.
IIRC, the rumored demand from Minnesota was Melky Cabrera, Phil Hughes and Ian Kennedy. My recollection is that I maintained that Ian Kennedy sucked (career potential fourth starter at best), but that Phil Hughes and Melky Cabrera were more valuable than Johan Santana.
Fast forward to May 5th.
Ian Kennedy sucks. Score one.
Phil Hughes was pitching with a cracked rib. The rumor I've heard is that he cracked the rib while he wasn't pitching. That actually makes sense, especially given that it's not a first rib. Hughes had a great first start, allowing two runs in six innings vs. Toronto for the win. After that he's had an absurdly bad 11.25 ERA, almost double what you'd expect from an average replacement-level pitcher. Hughes is better than replacement-level: we just don't know how much better yet. If he allowing an 11.25 ERA and a cracked rib shows up, though, one can believe that there's a correlation. No score yet on Hughes.
Melky Cabrera is leading the New York Yankees--the team of All Star sluggers--in home runs, and batting over .290, while playing a good defensive center field. It appears that he's found his power, as I'd suggested that he would. Score one more...that's two.
Johan Santana...well, he's 3-2 with a 2.91 ERA and an xFIP to match (3.07). He's the 13th-best pitcher in MLB by VORP this morning. That looks really good, but consider these factors:
1) Offense is down in 2008. That 2.91 ERA is an ERA+ of just 138, barely better than his 2006 ERA+ of 130 and much worse than his ERA+ from every year between 2002 and 2006.
2) That doesn't consider his AL-to-NL move. Given the league differences, an ERA+ of 138 in the NL might translate to something in the range of a 125 ERA+ in the AL. That's still very good for a starting pitcher, but it's less good than Santana ever was with the Twins.
3) Santana couldn't hit 92 mph his last time out (I checked Pitch f/x). Remember Buster Olney on ESPN Insider writing that Santana's velocity was off in his last seven starts of 2007? He hasn't regained his 94-96mph fastball. That suggests injury.
4) Santana is signed through the 2013 season at a total of $137.5 million, plus either a $5.5 million buyout or a $25 million contract year in 2014. That's A LOT of money, even for the Yankees.
We'll see...too early to score.
***
I claim a 2-0 score in my favor so far in assessing the potential trade. Even with Hughes on the DL and Kennedy in AAA, I'm sorry that the Yankees didn't make the deal. :dunno: